Consumer Reports recently compared two pairs of black pumps: a $500 pair from Manolo Blahnik and a $69 pair from Nine West. Their conclusion? The Manolos were superior in terms of fabric, construction, and overall quality. That’s probably true, but a fairer comparison might have been between Manolos and Stuart Weitzman shoes.
Weitzman shoes, priced between $150 and $200, aren’t exactly cheap, but they’re far more affordable than Manolos. Having owned both (purchased on sale, of course), I found my Weitzmans to be much more comfortable while still being just as stylish—and they cost about half as much.
If you’re wondering whether designer shoes like Manolo Blahniks are worth the investment, here are five key questions to consider:
1. No matter how trendy a shoe is, if you can’t walk in it, don’t buy it. Simple as that. When shopping, always try the shoes on and walk around on a carpeted surface for at least five minutes. I do this everywhere, even at Target. If they still feel good, they’re keepers. If not, back they go.
2. Want to test how well the fabric will hold up? Here’s a quick trick: Rub your finger on your skin, then lightly rub the shoe’s fabric. If the nap looks worn or your finger leaves a mark, that material might not be very durable. Just be careful—don’t try this if you’ve skipped a shower or gone overboard with lotion, or you’ll stain the shoe.
3. Expensive shoes often have leather soles, but keep in mind that leather wears out faster than wood or synthetic materials.
4. The heel should feel sturdy and securely attached to the shoe. If it wobbles or feels unstable, that’s a red flag.
5. If you’re spending a significant amount on shoes, they should come with individual dust bags for storage. It’s a small detail, but it speaks to the overall quality and care put into the product.